‘The Best Ever’ series counts down our favorite covers of great artists.
Last week, R.E.M. released a 25th anniversary expanded reissue of their 1994 album Monster. Unlike many of their albums, Monster was not an obvious candidate for a splashy box set. Practically every new review has noted that Monster was, as Salon succinctly put it, “a notorious staple of dollar bins everywhere.” But, as tends to happen with such reissues, the celebrated albums get celebrated again and the less-loved albums get a critical reappraisal. Sure enough, everyone loves Monster all of a sudden.
So perhaps an avalanche of Monster covers is forthcoming – because there certainly aren’t many now. Despite that being the ostensible news peg for this list, no songs from that album appear on it. But, in a band with as rich a discography as R.E.M.’s, there was a lot of competition. Sure, the obvious hits get covered as much as you think, but many artists delve deeper. The song at the very top of the list, for instance, originally appeared on 1998’s Up, an album that might have an even worse reputation than Monster.
Luckily we don’t need to wait four more years for the reappraisal of that, or of any of the other songs on our list. These 25 covers reappraise R.E.M. deep cuts you didn’t know and reimagine the hits you’ve heard a million times.
The list starts on Page 2.
This was interesting but I was hoping for the reverse:Songs covered by REM…
Wow! Nice collection but surprised that there’s no Tori Amos, The Corrs, Dashboard Confessional (full album of covers), Matthew Sweet and Susanna Hoffs, the compilations Welcome To The Occupation: A Reverence to R.E.M. and Finest Worksongs: Athens Bands Play the Music of R.E.M., as well as the Helping Haiti charity single.
I nominated Patterson Hood’s “Don’t Go Back to Rockville” from Finest Worksongs, but sadly it didn’t make the cut.
On your #9 pick, Dar Williams sings lead. Aside from that, I completely agree with your description of CCC’s version!