Last Monday, America woke up and didn’t want to get out of bed. There was yet another senseless massacre, this time in Las Vegas. Even more traumatic for us music fans, it took place in our church, at a concert venue. Later in the afternoon, the news broke that Tom Petty had died, and, a few hours on, that Tom Petty had died a second time. It was like we were getting sucker punched over and over again.
His words made us feel better: that losing is part of life, but we should never give up hope. That the world may drag us down, but people will be there for us. And that we should be free to chase our dreams, whether it be deep within ourselves or making them part of the world. We shouldn’t back down because Tom wouldn’t. To bullies, to being ostracized, and to being anything but ourselves.
Petty was a classic rock and roll survivor, ruling radio in the 1970s, winning MTV video music awards in the ’80s, and writing the song that came back from the dead to be the only happy moment in Silence of the Lambs in the ’90s. He recorded some of America’s most anthemic and heartfelt music, and although his later output declined some, he never slowed down, collaborating in the supergroup The Traveling Wilburys and becoming Johnny Cash’s sideman with the Heartbreakers, reforming his old band Mudcrutch, and endlessly touring.
Upon the news of his death, artists starting playing tribute covers immediately, both in the studio and onstage. I’ve listened to a few dozen over the past few days. Here are my favorites.
Wilco — The Waiting (Tom Petty and the Heartbreakers cover)
Jeff Tweedy is not exactly on his game when it comes to singing the words here, but the spirit (and the similarity between his and Petty’s voice) comes though loud and clear.
Against Me! — Runnin’ Down a Dream (Tom Petty cover)
Laura Jane Grace is the symbolic outsider in rock and roll, someone who pushed past Bowie’s gender-bending and said, “This is not a costume.” Before the song, she talks about the comfort Petty gave her growing up. After that, it’s just wide open glory.
Little Steven and the Disciples of Soul — Even the Losers (Tom Petty and the Heartbreakers cover)
The E-Streeter brings out his inner Springsteen (and his 13-piece band) to flesh out Petty’s most hopeful song.
Fleet Foxes — Don’t Come Around Here No More (Tom Petty cover)
This clip is really just Robin Pecknold with an acoustic guitar, but it shows you that even stripped down, with Petty, nothing is lost.
Larkin Poe — Wildflowers (Tom Petty cover)
“Wildflowers” is perhaps the most covered song in the past few days, and this may be the loveliest. Read our recent feature on Larkin Poe.
Father John Misty — To Find A Friend (Tom Petty cover)
“To Find a Friend” is also from Wildflowers, one of Petty’s best albums. No other song seems as fitting for last rites.
Chris Wimberley — Love Is A Long Road (Tom Petty cover)
Chris is a friend who owns a studio in Carrboro, North Carolina, and that space allows him to do a more polished video than some of the shaky phone cam videos above. Tributes are usually hastily put together at live shows, sometimes spontaneously, because death isn’t always on the calendar. As a result, many artists end up recording the exact same song over the course of days after a musician has passed on.
Chris goes a little deeper in Petty’s catalog with a song from 1989’s Full Moon Fever. He reworks the melody to better effect, stripping out the ’80s keyboard sound for the warmth of an acoustic guitar. As his voice breaks high in the chorus, like anybody covering a song, he makes it a little bit his own.
Is there a recent cover that’s not here that speaks to you? Share a link to it in the comments.
2 Responses to “RIP Tom Petty: The Best Posthumous Covers (So Far)”